Palworld: The ‘Pokémon with Guns’ phenomenon facing backlash

• Palworld, dubbed ‘Pokémon with guns,’ faces backlash for its resemblance to the Nintendo classic.
• Palworld‘s success topped sales charts and showed demand for fresh takes on classic gaming genres.
• Palworld‘s launch spotlights ethical AI use in gaming and underscores the pressing issue of harassment towards game developers.

The iconic Nintendo game, Pokémon, is currently in the limelight, but not for reasons related to a new game update. Instead, it’s because of a new game named Palworld, which resembles Pokémon in many ways, but with a twist—it’s labeled as ‘Pokémon with guns.’

Palworld‘s unassuming debut and meteoric rise

Initially, Palworld made a quiet entry into the gaming world about a year ago through a teaser. This first glimpse failed to garner significant attention, as many in the gaming community brushed it off as just another clone of the beloved Pokémon series, likely to fade into obscurity. But Palworld defied these early expectations with its recent Early Access release.

The game has not only captured gamers’ interest but has also shattered sales records, selling millions of copies in a remarkably short period. This sudden surge in popularity indicates a latent demand for a game that captures the essence of the Pokémon experience but innovates on the concept in a modern context—a demand that the original Pokémon franchise has been slow to fulfill.

The success of Palworld has far exceeded the expectations of its developers, the Japanese gaming company Pocketpair, previously known for its title Craftworld. The game’s impressive sales figures in its first week, with over 5 million copies sold and a peak of 1.5 million concurrent players on Steam, have placed Palworld among the most successful AAA games in recent years. This accomplishment is particularly notable given the initial skepticism surrounding the game’s potential.

What makes Palworld stand out is its ability to resonate with many gamers. Its appeal stems from various factors: the genuine interest of Pokémon enthusiasts in a similar yet distinct gaming experience, the challenge it poses to the established norms set by Nintendo and Game Freak, the curiosity it incites among gamers, and its attractive price point, which is set under US$30. This combination of factors has contributed to the game’s widespread popularity and commercial success.

Palworld dominating the gaming market

In the competitive gaming market, Palworld has made a notable impact.

The game recently topped Steam’s bestseller list, outperforming significant releases such as Call of Duty and Baldur’s Gate 3. Its popularity extends beyond PC gaming, as Palworld is also available on Xbox consoles through the Game Pass subscription service. This broad availability has played a significant role in the game’s rapid ascent in the gaming world.

Despite its commercial success, Palworld has not been immune to controversy. The game’s initial trailer, which depicted a dystopian world with parallels to Pokémon, drew skepticism and ridicule. In response, Pocketpair, the Tokyo-based studio behind Palworld, had to clarify that their creation was a legitimate endeavor and not a scam.

The controversial trailer presented a striking contrast between serene fantasy activities like farming, and shepherding, and intense gun battles, where animals were used as shields. Early descriptions on Steam even highlighted the role of creatures in automated factory settings, working tirelessly throughout their lifespans.

The version of Palworld released last weekend, however, has shifted the focus towards the domestication and interaction with over a hundred different creatures in the wild. This change in the game’s direction showcases the evolving nature of Palworld and its ability to adapt to player feedback and market trends.

How is Palworld similar to Pokémon?

Palworld‘s resemblance to Pokémon has been a topic of significant debate within the gaming community. Takuro Mizobe, CEO of Pocketpair, addressed these comparisons in a 2021 interview with The Gamer, emphasizing that Palworld was more akin to a survival game, drawing inspiration from various popular titles like Minecraft, Dragon Quest, and Grand Theft Auto.

More recently, Mizobe confirmed in an interview with Automaton that the game had successfully undergone legal review, highlighting Pocketpair’s commitment to respecting the intellectual property rights of other companies.

Despite Mizobe’s statements, the debate continues, with gamers and critics alike comparing Palworld and Pokémon. Some users have pointed out similarities not only with Pokémon but also with other franchises and even ancient Egyptian mythology, which appears to have influenced character designs in both games. This ongoing discussion reflects the complex nature of creative inspiration and the fine line between homage and imitation in the gaming industry.

Adding to the controversy surrounding Palworld is the speculation that its creators may have utilized generative AI to create its creature designs. While there is no concrete evidence to support this claim, the possibility has been acknowledged by various sources, including TechCrunch.

The idea that AI tools could have been used to generate Pokémon-like designs is not far-fetched, considering the advancements in AI technology and the availability of text-to-image generators like Stable Diffusion, which have made the creation of custom Pokémon a reality for many enthusiasts. This speculation adds another layer to the debate about Palworld‘s originality and the ethical implications of using AI in game design.

The industry’s response and player reactions

In response to the ongoing discussions about Palworld, The Pokémon Company has chosen to remain silent, while Pocketpair has not provided immediate comments.

However, the gaming community continues to draw parallels between Palworld and Pokémon, with numerous content creators discussing and analyzing the topic on platforms like YouTube and Twitch. The debate has extended beyond the gaming industry’s confines, capturing a wider audience’s attention and sparking conversations about creativity, intellectual property, and the evolution of gaming.

The controversy surrounding Palworld‘s launch has also highlighted a darker aspect of the gaming industry: harassment and toxicity towards developers. IGN reported that the game’s release was marred by death threats against its developers, a disturbing trend that has become increasingly prevalent in the gaming world.

This issue was further underscored in a recent Game Developers Conference survey, where a staggering 91% of the 2,300 developers surveyed identified player harassment and toxicity as a significant problem, with 42% considering it “very serious.” This situation underscores the need for a more respectful and constructive dialogue within the gaming community.

Despite its remarkable success, Palworld faces several challenges as it navigates the complex landscape of the gaming industry. The Xbox version of the game lags in features and updates compared to the Steam version, highlighting the difficulties of maintaining parity across different platforms. Additionally, the game’s massive launch has put a strain on its servers, a common challenge for popular online games that experience a sudden influx of players.

Palworld‘s journey from an overlooked teaser to a best-selling game is a testament to the dynamic and unpredictable nature of the gaming industry. Its parallels to Pokémon have sparked widespread debate and discussions about creativity, inspiration, and the boundaries of intellectual property.

As Palworld continues to navigate the complexities of success and controversy, it stands as a prominent example of the ever-evolving landscape of video games and the enduring influence of iconic franchises like Pokémon.

---

---

---